Remote Work Sidelining Young Grads More Than AI, New Study Finds

Stay up to date with our Up First newsletter sent every weekday morning.

College graduates entering the job market have been met with unexpected challenges, and recent data suggests that remote work, not artificial intelligence, is a significant factor impacting their employment prospects.

A study conducted by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York indicates that recent graduates face hurdles in securing jobs suitable for remote work, as employers express concerns about the effectiveness of learning in a remote setting.

Employment data and insights from a Fortune 500 tech company reveal a reluctance to hire new grads for positions that allow remote work, potentially due to the challenges of mentorship and learning from colleagues at a distance.

In analyzing the job market, the researchers discovered a 20% increase in unemployment among college graduates under 29 since the pandemic, while older graduates saw a slight decrease.

The investigation into employment trends between 2022 and 2024 shows a correlation between the rise in remote work and increasing unemployment rates among recent graduates, suggesting that remote work hampers effective training and mentorship.

Remote Work and Feedback Deficiencies

The research, led by Emma Harrington from the University of Virginia, initially focused on feedback received by software engineers at a major tech firm. The findings revealed that engineers working in proximity to colleagues received 20% more feedback than those working remotely, a trend consistent even before the pandemic.

However, after the pandemic, the feedback deficit became more pronounced and disproportionately affected younger employees, who typically require more guidance in their early careers.

As remote work became more prevalent, the company shifted hiring practices, favoring older candidates over younger, recent graduates for remote-capable positions.

Once the company reinstated an office-based work policy, it resumed hiring new graduates, indicating that mentoring challenges influenced hiring decisions.

Wider Economic Implications

The researchers expanded their study to assess whether the tech company’s experience reflected broader trends. They categorized jobs into “remotable” and “non-remotable” based on their suitability for remote work.

The findings showed that unemployment rates for young graduates in remote-capable roles rose significantly post-pandemic, while older graduates experienced a slight decrease in unemployment.

The research attributes two-thirds of the unemployment increase among young graduates to the rise in remote work during this period.

AI’s Role in Employment Trends

Although AI is often blamed for job disruptions, this study found no direct correlation between AI exposure and rising unemployment among recent grads from 2022 to 2024. Instead, the shift to remote work was a more significant factor, though the impact of AI could evolve over time.

Similar conclusions were drawn by researchers at the London School of Economics, who observed that remote work, rather than AI, more significantly affects early-career hiring across various countries.

The New York Fed report highlights the long-term effects of high unemployment rates among young college graduates, suggesting that early-career challenges could lead to lower earnings and slower career advancements compared to peers entering the workforce in more favorable conditions.