In the hallowed halls of Harvard University, a new academic concern is making waves—grade inflation. Recent findings indicate that over 60% of grades awarded to Harvard students are A’s, a significant increase from two decades ago. This issue has sparked a broader conversation about the evolving landscape of higher education and evaluation standards.
Unpacking the Reasons Behind Grade Inflation
Harvard’s recent report highlights a 25% increase in A grades over the last 20 years. While some attribute this trend to diminished academic standards, Ian Bogost, a professor at Washington University in St. Louis and contributor to The Atlantic, suggests the situation is more nuanced. He explains, “students have gotten a lot better,” and the admissions process at prestigious institutions like Harvard is highly selective, meaning admitted students might indeed deserve higher grades.
Moreover, Bogost points out that educational paradigms have shifted. Modern curriculums often emphasize projects and assignments over traditional exams, potentially affecting grade distributions. Another factor is the employment landscape for faculty, where nearly 75% of U.S. professors are non-tenured. Their job security often depends on student evaluations, creating an incentive to award higher grades.
The Student-Customer Dynamic
Ian Bogost also addresses a broader trend in academia: students are increasingly viewed as customers. “When you’re at college and you’re spending, you know, a hundred thousand dollars a year in some cases, it’s impossible for the situation not to become one that’s more customer-like,” he notes. This shift is partly driven by the rising costs of education and the emphasis on student satisfaction, wellness, and lifestyle amenities offered by universities.
Observations from the Academic Frontline
Reflecting on his experiences in humanities and computer science, Bogost observes a notable change in student attitudes over his 20-year teaching career. Students today are more focused on understanding what they must do to achieve an A, a trend he believes limits their engagement with the material. “Part of the assessment of a student is making them come to the table and figure out what it is that we’re asking for,” he explains.
Understanding the Broader Implications
While grade inflation is a pressing concern, Bogost views it as symptomatic of larger systemic issues. He emphasizes the need to address underlying factors such as accreditation systems and institutional pressures rather than simply adjusting grading practices. “When the grades are going up, but the level of performance or mastery that the grade is meant to measure is not going up, that does seem like a problem that we should address,” Bogost warns.
Ultimately, Bogost asserts that solving the issue of grade inflation requires acknowledging its complexity and moving beyond simplistic explanations of student and faculty behavior.
Accuracy and availability of NPR transcripts may vary. Transcript text may be revised to correct errors or match updates to audio. Audio on npr.org may be edited after its original broadcast or publication. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.
